Bullish on bullion? Here are the best ways to invest in gold
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/61ce4/61ce429743192b123d99165616e75132ff6ddf99" alt=""
I would like to add some gold to my portfolio as a hedge against the political and economic upheaval we’ve seen recently. In your opinion, what is the best way to get exposure to gold, and how much should I own?
With the price of gold surging about 45 per cent in the past year and hitting fresh record highs this month, more investors are turning to gold to add some juice to their portfolios and to hedge against uncertainty. Central banks have also been adding to their bullion holdings to diversify their foreign currency reserves.
If you’re keen on owning gold, my advice is to indulge in moderation. Yes, gold has been on a roll recently, but there are no guarantees the rally will continue. Moreover, unlike a stock or bond, gold pays no dividends or interest, so the only way to come out ahead is to sell your gold at a higher price than you paid for it. For these reasons, I believe a percentage allocation in the single digits is plenty for most people.
That said, I’ve never owned gold personally – except for my wedding ring – but I believe the metal does have benefits as a store of value and as a tool for diversification.
There are several different ways to invest in gold, each with its own pros and cons.
If you want to own physical gold directly, you can buy gold bars or coins from an online dealer or in person. Shop around for the best price and be sure to read customer reviews to make sure you are dealing with a reputable company. Regardless of where you buy your physical gold, you will pay a premium over the spot price of bullion. When you sell, you’ll take another haircut.
These price spreads are not trivial.
When I checked online bullion dealer silvergoldbull.ca earlier this week, the difference between the company’s selling and buying prices for a one-ounce gold bar produced by the Royal Canadian Mint was about $250. What’s more, you’ll face additional costs if you decide to insure your physical gold and store it securely in a safe deposit box at the bank, with the dealer or in a home safe.
If you want to avoid the hassles and expense of holding physical gold, buying an exchange-traded fund that owns gold may be the way to go. Gold ETFs trade on a stock exchange and are therefore more liquid than owning gold bars or coins directly. They have reasonable management expense ratios, and many gold ETFs come in both currency-hedged and non-hedged versions.
Examples include the iShares Gold Bullion ETF (ticker: CGL.C; MER: 0.55 per cent), its hedged counterpart (CGL; 0.56 per cent), the BMO Gold Bullion ETF (ZGLD; 0.23 per cent) and the hedged version (ZGLH; 0.23 per cent). The Royal Canadian Mint also offers exchange-traded receipts (MNT; 0.35 per cent) that provide investors with an interest in gold bullion held in custody by the mint, which is a federal Crown corporation.
A third option is to invest in gold mining stocks. This approach has the potential to offer higher returns than owning the commodity itself, because miners’ profits are leveraged to the price of gold. Many gold stocks also pay modest dividends, which may appeal to income-oriented investors. Another benefit is that some miners hedge part of their production to protect against swings in the price of the commodity.
However, mining is a risky business, which means it is important to do your due diligence before investing in any gold stock. Among Canada’s major gold producers, Agnico Eagle Mines Ltd. AEM-T is highly regarded by analysts for its strong free cash-flow generation, solid balance sheet and growth potential. Agnico Eagle’s quarterly dividend of 40 US cents equates to a yield of about 1.6 per cent, with the potential for the dividend to grow in the years ahead.
All 12 analysts who cover Agnico Eagle rate the stock a “buy,” with an average price target of $145.83, according to Refinitiv. The shares were trading Friday afternoon at about $138 on the Toronto Stock Exchange.
If the idea of owning individual gold mining stocks makes you nervous, consider an ETF that holds a basket of gold producers, such as the BMO Equal Weight Global Gold Index ETF (ZGD) or the iShares S&P/TSX Global Gold Index ETF (XGD).
Gold has been shining recently as geopolitical instability and economic uncertainty cause investors to look for safe-haven assets. Gold can help to diversify your portfolio and has the potential to provide capital gains over the long run. If you keep your exposure to gold modest, shop around for the best prices and focus on high-quality producers, you’ll be golden.
E-mail your questions to jheinzl@globeandmail.com. I’m not able to respond personally to e-mails but I choose certain questions to answer in my column.